celtic_godess has apologized for the scamming slight

i have been accused of scamming and this is the original transaction from sunday morning
robur: selling HE 4000 6gc each
[PM to robur: ill will b uy]
[PM from robur: where are you?]
You are too far away! Get closer!
robur was notified, now wait to see if s/he wants to trade with you.
robur: sorry folks sold alread
You have been saved!
robur: thank you
[PM to robur: thanks]
robur: also selling FE 3000
Shishio: -500kgc ea?
Shishio:
robur: ENRICHED FIRE ESSENCE
Shishio: Good Job
jjhedgerow: congratulations
robur: i been off for some time had radu made these more common?
digger: no
8 hours later
[PM from Celtic_Goddess: why did you scam my guildie]
[PM from robur: hello]
[PM to robur: excuse me?]
[PM to Celtic_Goddess: excuse me?]
[PM from Celtic_Goddess: potion of summoning is not worth 4k]
[PM from Celtic_Goddess: he didn;t know better]
[PM to Celtic_Goddess: i think you have the wrong person]
You gained 44 extra harvesting exp.
[PM from Celtic_Goddess: no]
[PM from robur: i find out you underpaid me for HE]
[PM from Celtic_Goddess: robur sold you 4K HEs for 28K gc]
#GM from Nerdz: huh?
[PM from robur: with WORTHLESS book of summoning ]
[PM from Celtic_Goddess: you gave him 24K and a pot of summoning book and said to sell the book]
You can't do that while trading!
Nerdz aborted the trade.
[PM to Celtic_Goddess: he asked for that price]
[PM from robur: got something to say?]
[PM from Celtic_Goddess: now come on, you and I know damn well HEs are not 6 gc ea]
[PM to robur: you announced the price in sto]
BlueButterfly: *****
[PM to Celtic_Goddess: what guild are you with]
[PM from Celtic_Goddess: BoC, robur's guild]
#GM from SlimPickins: it's when something goes wrong
[PM from Celtic_Goddess: his english is not good and people take advantage of him and I really don't like that]
[PM from Celtic_Goddess: he's a n00b, but not a bad kid ]
[PM to Celtic_Goddess: i gave him a book for free i didnt charge him for it]
[PM to Celtic_Goddess: i did not tell him to sell the book
[PM from Celtic_Goddess: well he is getting me the screenie now and we will see]
[PM to Celtic_Goddess: let me see if i can get the original text from this morning]
#GM from Nerdz: or what happend JJ?
[PM from Celtic_Goddess: if he is confused, I will owe you an apology, if he is telling the trueth, there will be a disputes post]
[PM from Celtic_Goddess: well he is getting me the screenie now and we will see]
[PM to Celtic_Goddess: let me see if i can get the original text from this morning]
#GM from Nerdz: or what happend JJ?

a week later

Celtic_Goddess: I'm sorry for the trouble he caused and how it made you feel
jjhedgerow: no problem
Celtic_Goddess: have a good day
jjhedgerow: you too happy hunting